"I am always very happy with my orders. But this time, I received an incorrect order. I ordered 1 chicken cutlet Parmesan hero and 1 meatball Parmesan hero. I received 2 meatball parm and no chicken cutlet. I didn’t bother to call to correct the order, the meatball parm hero was delicious."

"September 06, 2022"

"Food can be delicious but, unfortunately, the place lacks consistency. They often ignore “special requests” such as a different dressing or substitution request. They’re good, not great."

"May 06, 2022"

"This place went downhill. Food has changed. Service is terrible. Hung up on when calling. 2hr deliveries."

"July 16, 2021"

anonymous

"Excellent new restaurant to open in Annadale. The menu has lots of options and so far everything tried was just right. Sandwiches are stuffed, even main entrees was good. Broccoli Rabe excellent. Italian egg rolls delicious."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"Ordered a few pizzas this weekend. They were ok. Delivered hot and fresh... still not exactly what I am looking for in terms of crust. I'm not sure why it is so hard to find a decent pizza crust in the Annadale area."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"Well I ordered two hours ago and still no food if I didn't prepay I would have canceled!!!"

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"First I have to say the staff was super nice , I thoroughly enjoyed the food. So nice to have a place on the south shore that's not the same old pizzeria ..I usually go to the north shore to eat because of the variety , finally there is a place near my home that is worth going out to dinner for . I'm sure there are a few kinks with a new place but my experience was absolutely perfect ."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"I had already ordered from this newest pizza in Annadale around 4 times and each time it is consistent in speed of delivery and quality of the food, have dined in as well. So far always arrived hot, the menu has lots of options. We were actually worried when Angelo's was replaced that this place would take on a new age approach similar to Twisted Dish around the block, we would have hated it. But Pizza Parlor seems to be remaining to it's traditional roots and gives a real neighborhood feel."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"Ordered today based on precious feedback and I am so grateful I discovered this restaurant that I had to due diligence and write my own review. We ordered the Greek God white pie and the uncle Carmina baked sandwich. Stunning food really good. The pie is different we have never seen it before on any pizza menu and had to try it. It was perfect really tasted like Greek cuisine with feta, olives, greens and lemon - just tasty. The carmine sandwich was excellent as well. Plenty of left overs next time will try a salad and a sandwich, as the sandwich is good enough to share. And 5 stars to other reviewers for pointing out this place ."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"The food was amazing! We ordered it for the first time tonight and it definitely was a great choice. Portions were huge"

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"the shrimp Fra Diavolo dish was was excellent the sauce tasted home made and fresh."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"The food I give 5 stars . I just don't understand why it takes so long to deliver the food. The young man who came to my door was great. I hate ordering from because it takes so long. I hope you can get that fixed"

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"A gourmet restaurant with pizza prices. the burgers are better than any burger shops we tried. the meat is high quality, prepared really well and the selection is unbeatable. the management has listened to suggestions and they now have two type of plain pies, classic Angelo's style, and new Pizza parlor style. I tend to go for the classic, with shredded mozzerella over the new style which is squares of mozzerella. both are good, but the original is not as thin and crispy which I like better, the new style compares ciro which is really good but I prefer classic nyc. the sandwiches, rolls, sandwich knots are all good as well and the selection leaves nothing to be desired."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"I love this place the food is so good I would go back here. I enjoyed everything we ate I really like the wings and my burger was out of this world have nothing to complain about here"

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"My daughter raves about this place so we ordered tonight. I had chicken hero with fresh mozzarella on garlic bread. Omg so much garlic on it I could hardly eat it!!!i actually love garlic but this was way too much!!! Don’t think I’ll be ordering from here again."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"Great food with a great atmosphere. Highly recommend this place from the pizza to paninis to all of the entrees."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"Great paninis"

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"Very nice service and excellent lasagna. It tasted like your Italian grandma made it. Delicious gravy/sauce."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"I love this place so much. I go with my family all the time. It has such a nice atmosphere. The staff is super nice , Mike one of the owners was walking around greeting everyone he was so pleasant. My favorite was the parlor knots and the vodka sauce was to die for. The burgers are super fresh and delicious."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"Was a little leery about trying a burgher from a pizza parlor but gave it a shot. The burgher was better than any diner on the Island. You have to try it! The french fries were great too."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"Best Baked Clams on Staten Island, and maybe New York. I could eat trays of them Food is always fresh."

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"I have always loved the food here and the staff are always so very kind and accommodating. I want to especially thank everyone at the Pizza Parlor today when I picked up my order... I ordered online and requested the order be picked up later in the day, but they did not receive that special request and had it ready shortly after I submitted the order. They called me 90 minutes later to see when I was coming to pick up the order and I explained I had requested a later pick-up. They were so gracious and re-did the order without charging any extra, so my wife and I were extremely grateful. Please patronize this establishment as often as you can, they are truly WONDERFUL! Thank you Pizza Parlor!! You're the best!!"

"January 16, 2020"

anonymous

"Ordered a plain pie for delivery. An hour later I am told it's just getting out of the oven and will be out for delivery. The pizza I got was cold. The cheese was congealed. This is the 2nd time I've ordered from here and the 2nd time I've had issues. Gross."

"January 16, 2020"