WhereYouEat’s List of Best Pizza in New Dorp (10306) – Top Local Favorites
This list is not in any particular order. New Dorp (10306) has a strong mix of neighborhood classics, longtime family-owned pizzerias, and newer favorites that locals consistently return to. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice, ordering for family dinner, or looking for a specialty pie, these are the places New Dorp residents regularly rely on.
Each listing links to its full profile on WhereYouEat where you can browse menus, photos, specials and more.
This list is part of
WhereYouEat.com's TOP PIZZA LISTS
• Top North Shore Pizza
• Mid-Island Pizza
• South Shore Pizza
Rustic Pizza & Pasteria — New Dorp
Rustic Pizza & Pasteria has quickly become a local favorite in New Dorp thanks to its balance of traditional pizza and full Italian kitchen offerings. Their pies are known for fresh ingredients and consistent quality, while their broader menu makes it a great choice for both quick takeout and family dinners. Whether ordering a classic round pie or one of their specialty combinations, Rustic delivers dependable flavor that keeps locals coming back.
Best for: Specialty pies and full Italian kitchen options in a comfortable neighborhood setting.
View Listing: https://whereyoueat.com/Rustic-Pizza-&-Pasteria-10344.html
Ambrosino’s Pizza — New Dorp / Amboy Road
Ambrosino’s Pizza is a well-known Staten Island name that continues to maintain a strong following in the New Dorp area. Known for traditional Staten Island-style pizza, Ambrosino’s offers classic slices, Sicilian pies, and a wide variety of Italian favorites. It's the type of neighborhood pizzeria that balances quality and familiarity — exactly what locals want when ordering pizza regularly.
Best for: Classic Staten Island slices and dependable family pizza nights.
View Listing:
https://whereyoueat.com/Ambrosinos-Amboy-Rd-517.html
Avanti’s Pizza — New Dorp
Avanti’s Pizza is a neighborhood staple that locals often recommend by word-of-mouth. Their round pies and Sicilian slices are consistent favorites, and the restaurant focuses on delivering solid, dependable pizza without overcomplicating the menu. It's the kind of pizzeria people rely on for weeknight dinners, parties, or casual takeout.
Best for: Reliable everyday pies and classic Staten Island pizza flavor.
View Listing:
https://whereyoueat.com/Avantis-Pizza-New-Dorp-23276.html
Patrizia’s Pizza & Pasta — New Dorp
Patrizia’s Pizza & Pasta combines traditional pizza with a full Italian kitchen experience. Known for fresh ingredients and homemade-style dishes, Patrizia’s offers both classic pizza options and specialty pies alongside pasta, entrees, and family meals. It’s a great option for those looking for more than just a slice shop.
Best for: Family dinners, specialty pies, and full Italian menu options.
View Listing:
https://whereyoueat.com/Patrizias-Pizza-Pasta-new-28695.html
Justino’s Pizza — Guyon Avenue
Justino’s Pizza on Guyon Avenue is a true neighborhood favorite in New Dorp. Known for solid slices, generous portions, and dependable quality, Justino’s is a go-to for quick takeout or delivery. Their traditional New York-style pies and friendly neighborhood feel make it a comfortable and reliable option.
Best for: Classic slices, takeout, and dependable neighborhood pizza.
View Listing:
https://whereyoueat.com/Justinos-Pizzeria-771.html
Napoli Pizzeria — New Dorp
Napoli Pizzeria is a longtime local favorite serving New Dorp and surrounding neighborhoods. Known for fresh-made dough, classic Staten Island pies, and a full menu of Italian favorites, Napoli remains a dependable choice for both delivery and takeout. Their combination of value, quality, and consistency keeps customers coming back.
Best for: Classic pizza, fast delivery, and dependable family meals.
View Listing:
https://whereyoueat.com/Napoli-Pizza-30576.html
Plaza Pizza — New Dorp
Plaza Pizza is a familiar New Dorp spot that locals return to for traditional pizza and classic Italian comfort food. Known for its straightforward menu and consistent quality, Plaza Pizza offers both slices and full pies that deliver classic Staten Island flavor without overcomplication.
Best for: Classic NY-style pizza and reliable neighborhood takeout.
View Listing:
https://whereyoueat.com/Plaza-Pizza-new-729.html
Pizzeria Giove — New Dorp
Pizzeria Giove offers a slightly more elevated pizza experience while still maintaining neighborhood pizzeria charm. Known for quality ingredients and carefully crafted pies, Giove has built a loyal following among New Dorp locals looking for something just a bit different while still rooted in classic Staten Island pizza traditions.
Best for: Specialty pies and a slightly elevated neighborhood pizza experience.
View Listing:
https://whereyoueat.com/Pizzeria-Giove-304.html
Website: https://www.pizzeriagiovestatenisland.com/
These New Dorp (10306) pizzerias represent the spots locals truly rely on — whether grabbing a quick slice, ordering for family dinner, or finding your new go-to pizza place.
Explore more local restaurants, menus and pizza spots on
WhereYouEat.com — Discover Local Restaurants
