"You'd never mistake it for Basillio's or Denino's, but, at the same time, you'd know you weren't having A&M. This pizza comes pretty correct, and you can trust them to pull off a decent vodka sauce. You wouldn't rave about it to an out-of-towner relative, but if you want, you can trust them to pull off something a little out of the ordinary, like fried zucchini and bacon on a white pie."
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"The best Pizza I've found on the rock, Great pasta dishes too. I was going to Joe & PAt's until I tried Milano. Much better taste and value. And always fast service."
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"the first time I ordered from here the food was ok and it came quickly. the second time I ordered from there they said they don't deliver to my area only 3 weeks passed so the lady said she would refund my card. its been a week and the money still hasn't been refunded. I called several times and each time they say I should wait 2 to 3 days. Never getting food from there again"
"January 16, 2020"
shari!
"Fantastic Pizza & the rest of the Menu #ROCKS!"
"January 16, 2020"
beatriz
"I LOVE CAFE MILANO
IS THE BEST PIZERIA .
EVERY TIME I GO WITH MY FAMILY OR ORDER OUT WE ARE VERY PLEASE WITH THE FOOD."
"January 16, 2020"
Johnnyfahn
"Unfortunately went there with my wife on a Wednesday night. Apparently it was half price bottle of wine night, which went over a little too well with some of the patrons. There is nothing worse than a table of middle-aged bleach-blonde bimbos screaming at each other to ruin a fine meal.
As always, the dinner itself was quite good, and this is still one of my favorite sit-down Italian restaurants in the area, just would never go back on a Wednesday!"
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"I went there dor lunch today because I was in the area. I did not think much of it. The pizza is just ok. The sauce was a bit sweet and the cheese not full of flavor. It was ok for lunch."
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"my family and i come to milano quite often and sit and have dinner in the barrestaurant area...we love the atmosphere and the people...some of them some night the food is better then others and the drinks arent always on point, but what can you do. the staff for the most part is wonderful, we always have the same waiter and no matter what day of the week we go there its the same bus boy and we love them ! would defanitly recommend milano on a nice quiet sunday night"
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"Over priced, and took way too long to arrive at my house. I was told 30 minutes and after 45 still no pizza. I called and the girl was quite nasty. Guess you don't need my business"
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"Have to disagree with the last post. I think their prices are quite reasonable, if not below, then certainly average for the area although thanks to this site everyone can judge for themselves. I wouldn't say the food is the best I've ever had, or that I wouldn't prefer slightly larger portions, but it's certainly better than just decent. Definitely good value for the price. As for the long delivery time, it must have been a bad night. I've been ordering from them at least once every two weeks for years and I can't remeber an order ever taking over a half hour, usually it is closer to 15 mins."
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"The hottest guy in the world delivered my pizza this morning. His name was Darren. He was a tall drink of water. I hope he delivers the next time I order.
Gina."
"January 16, 2020"
anonymous
"Love this place!!"
"January 16, 2020"
regina
"Still no online ordering. The platform has been faulty for months."
"January 16, 2020"
gavone
"closing end of november ? Whats up with that ?"
"January 16, 2020"
Cafe Milano Pizzeria and Restaurant Located in Randall Manor neighborhood of Staten Island. Cafe Milano Pizzeria and Restaurant is open Today. Saturday November 23rd from 11:00 am -until 09:00 pm Delivery, is available. Serving Cafe, Pizzeria Cuisine
*WhereYouEat is a local restaurant search engine - we are not necessarily affiliated with any restaurant listed on our guide. We try to maintain accuracy of listings, but the data below is not verified or guaranteed, and may be outdated.
Subscribe to Exclusive WhereYouEat.com Deals for Cafe Milano Pizzeria and Restaurant & Other Nearby Announcements
By submitting your information, you give your Express Consent to receive Recurring Updates from WhereYouEat.com regarding Local Restaurant Promotions, Grand Openings & Other News.
Even if you are on a State or Federal Do-Not-Call List
We will send maximum of 5 Messages per week READ FULL DISCLAIMER
Disclaimer
By submitting your information, you give your Express Consent to receive recurring updates from WhereYouEat.com regarding Local Restaurant Promotions, Grand Openings & Other news. You will receive messages even if you are on any National or Local Do-Not-Call lists.
We won't share your details with any third parties, but may send out promotional messages from third parties looking to promote local restaurant related news, specials, events or happenings.
You Agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Please note that consent to receive messages is not a condition for any purchase. Standard message & data rates may apply. You can opt-out at any time by replying STOP to any of the messages. For additional information you can reply HELP or contact our customer care at 800-865-897
Subscribe for Email and/or Subscribe for SMS phone
"You'd never mistake it for Basillio's or Denino's, but, at the same time, you'd know you weren't having A&M. This pizza comes pretty correct, and you can trust them to pull off a decent vodka sauce. You wouldn't rave about it to an out-of-towner relative, but if you want, you can trust them to pull off something a little out of the ordinary, like fried zucchini and bacon on a white pie."
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"The best Pizza I've found on the rock, Great pasta dishes too. I was going to Joe & PAt's until I tried Milano. Much better taste and value. And always fast service."
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"the first time I ordered from here the food was ok and it came quickly. the second time I ordered from there they said they don't deliver to my area only 3 weeks passed so the lady said she would refund my card. its been a week and the money still hasn't been refunded. I called several times and each time they say I should wait 2 to 3 days. Never getting food from there again"
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"Fantastic Pizza & the rest of the Menu #ROCKS!"
shari!
"January 16, 2020"
"I LOVE CAFE MILANO
IS THE BEST PIZERIA .
EVERY TIME I GO WITH MY FAMILY OR ORDER OUT WE ARE VERY PLEASE WITH THE FOOD."
beatriz
"January 16, 2020"
"Unfortunately went there with my wife on a Wednesday night. Apparently it was half price bottle of wine night, which went over a little too well with some of the patrons. There is nothing worse than a table of middle-aged bleach-blonde bimbos screaming at each other to ruin a fine meal.
As always, the dinner itself was quite good, and this is still one of my favorite sit-down Italian restaurants in the area, just would never go back on a Wednesday!"
Johnnyfahn
"January 16, 2020"
"I went there dor lunch today because I was in the area. I did not think much of it. The pizza is just ok. The sauce was a bit sweet and the cheese not full of flavor. It was ok for lunch."
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"my family and i come to milano quite often and sit and have dinner in the barrestaurant area...we love the atmosphere and the people...some of them some night the food is better then others and the drinks arent always on point, but what can you do. the staff for the most part is wonderful, we always have the same waiter and no matter what day of the week we go there its the same bus boy and we love them ! would defanitly recommend milano on a nice quiet sunday night"
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"Over priced, and took way too long to arrive at my house. I was told 30 minutes and after 45 still no pizza. I called and the girl was quite nasty. Guess you don't need my business"
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"Have to disagree with the last post. I think their prices are quite reasonable, if not below, then certainly average for the area although thanks to this site everyone can judge for themselves. I wouldn't say the food is the best I've ever had, or that I wouldn't prefer slightly larger portions, but it's certainly better than just decent. Definitely good value for the price. As for the long delivery time, it must have been a bad night. I've been ordering from them at least once every two weeks for years and I can't remeber an order ever taking over a half hour, usually it is closer to 15 mins."
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"The hottest guy in the world delivered my pizza this morning. His name was Darren. He was a tall drink of water. I hope he delivers the next time I order.
Gina."
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"Love this place!!"
anonymous
"January 16, 2020"
"Still no online ordering. The platform has been faulty for months."
Cafe Milano Pizzeria and Restaurant Located in Randall Manor neighborhood of Staten Island. Cafe Milano Pizzeria and Restaurant is open Today. Saturday November 23rd from 11:00 am -until 09:00 pm Delivery,
Restaurants offering Alcohol/Beer/Wine is available. Serving Cafe, Pizzeria Cuisine
Our website uses cookies to enhance your browsing experience and provide relevant information. By continuing to use our site, you acknowledge and accept our Cookie Policy & Privacy